Whilst this case is a little older than my usual case updates, it is by no means less interesting and, in my humble opinion, important when it comes to considering decisions in family provision matters involving disentitling conduct and estrangement. In the case of Dawson v Joyner [2011] QSC 385, the deceased was survived by…
Tag: estate litigation
The Rise & Fall of the Gift & Loan Back: Re Permewan – on The Heir Waves
In the latest episode of my new podcast called The Heir Waves, Caite Brewer and I discussed some more interesting cases in succession law. Have a listen below: The Rise & Fall of the Gift & Loan Back: Re Permewan In this episode, Caite & Michele discuss: the case of Re Permewan (No 2) [2022] QSC 114…
Addiction & Conduct: FPA applicant receives legacy following tumultuous childhood (QLD)
I regularly research for my PhD and, lets be honest, for nerdy interest, for cases involving disentitling conduct. I recently spoke about this case on The Heir Waves podcast (Episode 1, to be exact) about the decisions of Hartley. I wanted to also post about it here for some further detail as I think the…
Super Scott: Superannuation with special guest Scott Hay-Bartlem – on The Heir Waves
In the latest episode of my new podcast called The Heir Waves, Caite Brewer and I discussed some more interesting cases in succession law. Have a listen below: Super Scott: Superannuation with special guest Scott Hay-Bartlem In this episode, Caite & Michele: are joined with special guest, Scott Hay-Bartlem, Partner and Superannuation guru at Cooper Grace Ward…
Be Wary to Vary and Exercise Discretion: Re Owies Family Trust – on The Heir Waves
In the latest episode of my new podcast called The Heir Waves, Caite Brewer and I discussed some more interesting cases in succession law. Have a listen below: Be Wary to Vary and Exercise Discretion: Re Owies Family Trust In this episode, Caite & Michele discuss: The family trust case of Re Owies Family Trust [2020] VSC…
Re Marsella and genuine and real consideration – on The Heir Waves
In the latest episode of my new podcast called The Heir Waves, Caite Brewer and I discussed some more interesting cases in succession law. Have a listen below: Freedom of Discretion: Re Marsella and ”real and genuine” consideration In this episode, Caite & Michele discuss: Follow up question from ‘Episode 1: To Love and To…
Mutual wills & disentitling conduct – on The Heir Waves
In the latest episode of my new podcast called The Heir Waves, Caite Brewer and I discussed some interesting cases, including one that involved mutual wills and another involving, my favourite topic, disentitling conduct. Have a listen below: Title: To love and to loathe: mutual wills and disentitling conduct In this episode, Caite & Michele…
“Estrangement explained”: FPA provision ordered following years of family disharmony
The case of McLeod v Napthali [2021] NSWSC 1621 really struck me as I read this brief judgement today. Great thanks and shout out to buddy Clifford Hughes for sharing this one with me (he understands my great love of all things estrangement and disentitling conduct in FPAs!). This is great humanity demonstrated by His…
Left out of Struggle Street; Right onto Found Freeway
A little update from me. I hope everyone is fairing as well as can be in the pandemic and everything that it has touched over these past 2 years. I wanted to write a slightly different blog post today. The first thing I want to do is apologise to anyone who frequents my blog for…
Executors behaving badly: Successful removal and IA appointed (QLD)
Getting an executor removed for undesirable behaviour can be quite the challenge in practice. Many elements are part of the equation including the conduct of the parties, the nature of the estate, the steps required to be taken to finalise the estate and the cost of appointing someone separately to administer the estate. Normally, the…
Leave ’em a loan: Liability to pay mortgage left with joint tenant
The liability of a mortgage is probably one of the most significant liabilities a couple will share. Whilst many times it’s a fairly equal distribution of that liability when everything is held jointly, it’s not always the case in circumstances of second/later relationships or a singular income earner and home maker. The recent decision of…
Family Values: successful FPA by trans woman, following estrangement & disharmony among family (VIC)
I recently read an interesting media article on a family provision case and had to look further into get to the bottom of it. It involves a case where an adult child made a claim against a father’s estate for further provision having received no provision from the estate under the father’s Will. What was…
Pandemic or Prejudice: FPA hearing vacated amid COVID-19 (ACT)
I sincerely hope this reaches my readers, followers, and passers-by in a situation where they are safe and well during this tumultuous time in the world! For those in litigation, your practice is changing daily as we wait (and wait) for certainty (if it is ever arrives!); and those hearings aren’t going anywhere.. or are…
Decision Impossible: FPA by disabled son against widow, forcing sale of family home in notional estate (NSW)
Recently, the NSW Supreme Court determined a very difficult family provision application by an adult son, in circumstances where the adult son was otherwise healthy when the deceased passed away, but subsequently suffered significant health issues following his father’s death. Further, the only available assets for such a family provision claim were via notional estate….
Duty Bound: solicitor’s duty to beneficiary of incapable testator after inter vivos transfer
It was in the context of preparing for the delivery of my recent presentation for The Tax Institute’s Death…and Taxes Symposium on the Gold Coast recently that I come to read a recent case of solicitor negligence in the context of estate planning. In the appeal decision of McFee v Reilly [2018] NSWCA 322, a…
Danger Zone: costs against plaintiff in FPA in small estate (NSW)
Family provision claims in small estates is an inherit danger zone for claimants and lawyers. The recent case of Wengdal v Rawnsley [2019] NSWSC 926 has demonstrated this again where Justice Hallen has ordered that the plaintiff’s claim be dismissed and the plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs on the ordinary basis. In this case, the deceased…
Missing element: High Court orders new trial in solemn form probate proceedings; denial of procedural fairness
It appears to be raining estate and trust law cases from the High Court of Australia over the last two weeks. Yesterday, the High Court of Australia ordered a new trial be held in relation to solemn form probate proceedings in Nobarani v Mariconte [2018] HCA 36 on the basis that the appellant as denied…
What is “Contemplation of marriage”: Marriage revokes Will in blended family (NSW)
Last week, the Supreme Court of New South Wales published a judgement in a estate matter where the question of whether a Will was “made in contemplation of marriage” was a central focus of their attention. In the case of Re Estate Grant, deceased [2018] NSWSC 1031, the deceased made a Will dated on about…
FPA 7 years out of time: Allowed on Appeal (WA)
In an unusual case published a few weeks ago, the Western Australian Court of Appeal allowed an extension of time for an adult son to bring a claim against his late father’s estate 7 years after the time limit expired. The claim was dismissed at first instance and the adult son appealed asserting 9 different…
“Divorced from reality”: Appeal allowed in former spouse FPA claim (NSW)
Earlier this year, I was surprised to read a judgement where a former spouse successfully claimed for further provision from her former husband’s estate notwithstanding the pair had completed a property settlement 25 years prior. You can read my earlier post here. It may come as no surprise that the matter was appealed to the…